Skip to main content

Table 3 Knowledge broker behaviours coded by level of experience

From: Deconstructing knowledge brokering for commissioned rapid reviews: an observational study

 

Knowledge broker behaviours

Very experienced brokers

Experienced brokers

Less experienced brokers

No consistent pattern

1

Asking closed questions

Yes

Yes

Yes

 

2

Asking open ended questions

Yes

Yes

Yes

 

3

Asking more detail

Yes

Yes

Yes

 

4

Building trust

Yes

Yes

Yes

 

5

Checking understanding

Yes

Yes

Yes

 

6

Managing the session

Yes

Yes

Yes

 

7

Diagnostics

Yes

Yes

Yes

 

8

Gaining agreement

Yes

Yes

Yes

 

9

Managing interludes

Yes

Yes

Yes

 

10

Letting them talk

Yes

Yes

Yes

 

11

Open dialogue

Yes

Yes

Yes

 

12

Pointing to problems or solutions

Yes

Yes

Yes

 

13

Positive regard

Yes

Yes

Yes

 

14

Referencing the reviewer

Yes

Yes

Yes

 

15

Reflecting back

Yes

Yes

Yes

 

16

Filtering

Yes

Yes

  

17

Frank disclosure

Yes

Yes

  

18

State re-state

Yes

Yes

  

19

Understanding context

Yes

Yes

  

20

Using humour

Yes

Yes

  

21

Negotiating

Yes

Yes

  

22

Setting expectations

Yes

Yes

  

23

Explaining

Yes

Yes

  

24

Power or ownership

Yes

Yes

  

25

Being neutral

Yes

   

26

Personal anecdote

Yes

   

27

Combining expertise

Yes

   

28

Frame-re-frame

Yes

   

29

Interplay of expertise

Yes

   

30

Highlighting inconsistencies

   

Yes

31

Accord and discord

   

Yes

32

Adding value

   

Yes

33

Testing constructs

   

Yes

34

No trust

   

Yes

35

Using examples

   

Yes