Skip to main content

Table 3 Assessment of the success of execution of local evaluations for MCP Vanguards (adapted from O'Cathain et al. [12])

From: Investigating the nature and quality of locally commissioned evaluations of the NHS Vanguard programme: an evidence synthesis

  BLC Birmingham Dudley Encompass Erewash S Notts Sunderland T Hamlets W Wakefield
Quantitative component feasible? No N/A Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Qualitative component feasible? Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Mixed methods design feasible? No Yes N/A Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Have both components been completed? No Yes N/A Yes No Unclear Yes No Yes
Quantitative methods planned, not executed? Yes N/A Unclear Yes Unclear Unclear No Yes No
Qualitative methods planned, not executed? No No Unclear Yes Yes Unclear No Unclear No
Did mixed methods design work in practice? No Yes N/A Yes No Unclear Yes No Yes
  1. No local evaluations commissioned by Calderdale or Lakeside Vanguards. No details available for Fylde Coast, Stockport or West Cheshire. Sunderland assessment based on the North East Vanguard evaluation