Skip to main content

Table 3 Additional themes not captured in the Proctor et al. (2012) checklist

From: How has implementation been incorporated in health technology assessments in the United Kingdom? A systematic rapid review

  Intervention Study type Process evaluation Barriers and facilitators Quantitative evaluation of implementation Included economic evaluation Clear recommendations for implementation Implementation as future work
Campbell et al. (2014) (28) Cardiac MRI in ischaemic cardiomyopathy Review and model  ×  ✓  ×  ✓  ×  ✓
Hood et al. (2014) (29) Probiotics for antibiotic-associated diarrhoea Cohort  ×  ✓  ×   ×  ✓  × 
Livingston et al. (2014) (30) Coping strategies for carers of people with dementia Randomized controlled trial (RCT) ✓  ×   ×  ✓  ×  ✓
Bonell et al. (2015) (12) Anti-bullying programme RCT  ×  ✓  ×   ×  ✓ ✓
Freeman et al. (2015) (31) Testing kits for Crohn’s disease Review and model  ×  ✓  ×  ✓ ✓ ✓
Guthrie et al. (2015) (32) Impact of NIHR HTA programme Review  ×   ×   ×   ×   ×   × 
Michie et al. (2015) (33) Taxonomy of behavioural change techniques Methods paper ✓ ✓  ×   ×  ✓ ✓
Richardson et al. (2015) (34) Screening for psychological and mental health issues in young people Review and model  ×  ✓  ×   ×   ×  ✓
Bailey et al. (2016) (35) Web-based sexual health app RCT ✓ ✓  ×   ×   ×  ✓
Field et al. (2016) (36) Lung cancer screening RCT  ×  ✓  ×  ✓ ✓ ✓
Fortnum et al. (2016) (37) School-entry hearing test screening Model  ×  ✓  ×  ✓ ✓  × 
Freeman et al. (2016) (38) My5-FU assay monitoring in chemotherapy patients RCT  ×  ✓  ×  ✓  ×   × 
Jackson et al. (2016) (39) Uptake of immunization in travelling and gypsy communities Qualitative interview  ×  ✓  ×   ×  ✓ ✓
Parry et al. (2016) (40) Cognitive behaviour therapy for fear of falling in older people RCT  ×  ✓  ×   ×  ✓ ✓
Paton et al. (2016) (41) Improving outcomes for people with mental health crises Review ✓ ✓  ×   ×   ×   × 
Tufail et al. (2016) (42) Diabetic retinopathy image assessment software Cohort study  ×   ×   ×  ✓ ✓  × 
Whitaker et al. (2016) (13) Programmes to reduce unintended pregnancies Review and model  ×  ✓  ×  ✓ ✓ ✓
Birrell et al. (2017) (43) Real-time influenza modelling Model  ×   ×   ×   ×   ×   × 
Flowers et al. (2017) (44) Behavioural change programme Review  ×  ✓  ×   ×  ✓  × 
Melendez-Torres et al. (2017) (45) Beta-interferon and glatiramer acetate for treating multiple sclerosis Review and model  ×   ×   ×   ×   ×   × 
Snooks et al. (2017) (46) Assessment of protocols for older people following a fall RCT  ×  ✓  ×  ✓  ×   × 
Soomro et al. (2017) (47) Surveillance for small renal tumours RCT ✓ ✓  ×   ×   ×   × 
Thomas et al. (2017) (48) Breathing retraining exercises in asthma patients RCT ✓ ✓  ×   ×   ×  ✓
Watson et al. (2017) (49) Family and social network intervention for young people who misuse drugs and alcohol RCT  ×  ✓  ×   ×  ✓ ✓
Waugh et al. (2017) (50) Spot protein-creatinine ratio and spot albumin-creatinine ratio to assess preeclampsia Model  ×   ×   ×  ✓  ×  ✓
Welton et al. (2017) (51) Screening strategies for atrial fibrillation Review and model  ×  ✓  ×  ✓ ✓ ✓
Williams et al. (2017) (52) Timing of surgical intervention for developmental dysplasia of the hip RCT  ×  ✓  ×   ×   ×   × 
Avenell et al. (2018) (53) Bariatric surgery Review and model  ×  ✓  ×  ✓  ×   × 
House et al. (2018) (54) Self-management in adults with type 2 diabetes and learning difficulties RCT  ×  ✓  ×  ✓ ✓  × 
McClurg et al. (2018) (55) Abdominal massage for neurogenic bowel dysfunction in multiple sclerosis RCT ✓ ✓  ×   ×  ✓ ✓
Paleri et al. (2018) (56) Gastronomy tube feeding in chemoradiation patients RCT ✓ ✓  ×   ×  ✓ ✓
Peron et al. (2018) (57) Colposcopy techniques for assessing cervical abnormalities Review and model  ×   ×   ×  ✓  ×   × 
Richards et al. (2018) (58) Psychological care in cardiac rehabilitation RCT ✓ ✓ ✓ ✓ ✓ ✓
Saramago et al. (2018) (59) Prenatal testing foetal rhesus D status Review and model ✓ ✓  ×  ✓ ✓  × 
Seguin et al. (2018) (15) Self-sampling kits for HIV testing Review, cohort study, and model ✓ ✓ ✓ ✓ ✓  × 
Allan et al. (2019) (60) An intervention to improve outcomes in falls in dementia RCT ✓ ✓  ×  ✓  ×  ✓
Griffin et al. (2019) (61) Management of fracture of the distal femur RCT ✓ ✓  ×  ✓  ×   × 
James-Roberts et al. (2019) (62) Support package for excessively crying infants RCT  ×  ✓  ×  ✓  ×  ✓
Madan et al. (2019) (63) Behaviour change package to prevent hand dermatitis RCT ✓ ✓  ×  ✓  ×   × 
Simmonds et al. (2019) (64) Imaging or detection of osteomyelitis Review  ×   ×   ×   ×   ×   × 
Francis et al. (2020) (65) Management of acute exacerbations of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease RCT ✓ ✓ ✓ ✓ ✓ ✓
Surr et al. (2020) (66) Dementia care mapping to reduce agitation in care home residents RCT ✓ ✓  ×  ✓ ✓ ✓
Back to article page

Health Research Policy and Systems

ISSN: 1478-4505

Contact us