Skip to main content

Table 2 Stage 3: TMF consensus review criteria based on T-CaST framework

From: The usability and applicability of knowledge translation theories, models, and frameworks for research in the context of a national health service

Criteria

Rating (0—3)

Additional comments

Acceptability: TMF is for health service use (include consideration of the extent of use)

  

Relevance: relevant to knowledge, dissemination and impact (with impact as less priority in this context)

  

Usability and acceptability: TMF that can be understood, applied and operationalized in the Irish Health Service

  

Usability and acceptability: the TMF has a clear and useful figure depicting included constructs and relationships among them

  

Usability and acceptability: the TMF provides a step by step approach for applying it

  

Usability and acceptability: the TMF provides methods for promoting implementation in practice

  

Validated: the TMF is supported by empirical data

  

Applicability: addresses a relevant analytic level; generalizable to relevant populations and/or conditions

  

Final decision to include or exclude: 0 = poor fit; 1 = moderate fit; 2 = good fit; 3 = very good fit

  
  1. A rating of “0” or “1” for any criteria means the final decision should be exclude but there may be exceptions to this—if so, please specify rationale in “additional comments”
Back to article page

Health Research Policy and Systems

ISSN: 1478-4505

Contact us