Skip to main content

Table 1 Characteristics of included studies (N = 141)

From: Knowledge management tools and mechanisms for evidence-informed decision-making in the WHO European Region: a scoping review

 

N

%

Type of study design

    Descriptive case studies

65

46.0

    Observational studies (e.g. qualitative, surveys, Delphi techniques)

42

29.8

    Literature/narrative reviews

9

5.6

   Opinion pieces/editorials/commentaries

7

5.0

   Technical reports

6

4.3

   Systematic reviews

4

2.8

   Quasi-experimental Studies

2

1.4

   Policy briefs

2

1.4

   Modelling studies

2

1.4

   Book

1

0.7

   Methodology paper

1

0.7

Classification of the country of the institution to which the first author is affiliateda

  

European high-income countries

135

95.7

   The United Kingdom

37

26.2

   The Netherlands

18

12.8

   Italy

12

8.5

   Germany

12

8.5

   Denmark

10

7.1

   Belgium

10

7.1

   Sweden

6

4.3

   Hungary

4

2.8

   Norway

4

2.8

 Other European high-income countries

22

15.6

 European upper middle-income countries

1

0.7

   Bulgaria

1

0.7

European lower middle-income countries

0

0.0

 European low-income countries

0

0.0

 Non-European countriesb

5

3.5

KM phase and typec

  

 Knowledge generation

11

7.8

   Indicators

8

5.7

   Surveys

3

2.1

  Knowledge storage

48

34.0

   Registries

21

14.9

   Surveillance tools, observatories, and data platforms

23

16.3

   Health information systems

4

2.8

 Knowledge processing

24

17.0

   Evidence synthesis

19

13.5

   Health reports and toolkits

5

3.5

 Knowledge transfer and utilization

59

41.8

   Evidence networks and collaborations

32

22.7

   Policy dialogues and stakeholders’ engagement

17

12.1

   Community engagement

5

3.5

   Decision support tools

5

3.5

Country subject of interventiona

 Regional level (i.e. WHO European Region)

68

48.2

 European high-income countries

70

49.6

 European upper middle-income countries

2

1.4

 European lower middle-income countries

1

0.7

 European low-income countries

0

0.0

Reporting of funding

  Reported as funded

77

54.6

  Reported as not funded

12

8.5

  Not reported

52

36.9

Reporting of conflict of interest

  Reported as no conflict of interest

73

51.8

  Reported as conflict of interest

17

12.1

  Not reported

51

36.2

  1. aAs per World Bank list of economies issued in June 2021
  2. bCountries outside the WHO European region
  3. cMore than one option can apply